Sa 2 t91 or sa 335 p91 is such a ferritic alloy steel that meets this condition. The type i and type ii cracking originate in weld metal, propagate either through the weld metal itself type i or cross over in the haz type ii. After the soak time, the material must be cooled at a controlled rate to prevent stressing the part, which could lead to cracking. Astm a335 grade p91 steel chemical composition, metal. This type of cracking is also known as underbead cracking, toe cracking, or delayed cracking.
Results are reported on the simulated specimens 11x11x70 mm tested at operating temperature. Ferritic alloys containing between 9 and 12 wt% chromium are seen as the. Piping failures have continued, in large numbers, despite p91s perceived superiority. Creep crack growth, p91 steel, weld joint, heat affected zone. Exposure to the intercritical region and the resulting reduction in strength leads to the type iv cracking found in many p91 welds. The weakest link with these materials is neither the base metal nor the weld metal, but the haz with regards to long term creep actually type iv cracking. Insight into type iv cracking in grade 91 steel weldments. Abstractthis paper describes the characterisation of residual stress in electron beam welded p91 ferriticmartensitic steel plates 9 mm thick by neutron diffraction and contour measurement methods. Because of the high creep strength of p91, the wall thickness is thinner than tha under the same conditions.
Type iv cracking is creep cracking which occurs at the parent materialheat affected zone haz interface in ferritic steel weldments. P91 pipe astm a335 p91 pipe asme sa335 p91 pipe supplier. In a type iv failure, cracking takes place in the finegrain. P91 material preferred for its unique properties, the unheat treated steel has great qualities as well as has an immense affinity to hydrogen. Although concrete is a very strong building material, it does have its limits. Usa astm astm a335 grade p91 seamless ferritic alloy steel pipe for hightemperature service and astm a335 grade p91 mechanical properties, chemical element, cross reference, datasheet. Normally, for this type of dissimilar metal weld dmw you want to locate it in a low stress region to avoid bending stress in the p91 base metal heat affected zone type 4 cracking. Whereas when using a b3 filler the carbon migration will be from the b3 filler to the p91 haz. The cracking was type iii creep cracking, and had initiated in the midwall region within bands of coarsegrained material. The pipes and elbows were having a diameter of 42 inches 1067mm and thickness of 52. The material does not have direct metallography properties.
The type iv cracking occurred not only in 9cr steel joints p91p92 8, but also in other dissimilar metal welds, for example, 9crinconel 617 9. Where an aws classification is shown, specific consumables are available from more than one source. The normalizing temperature is in the range of 104010808c and tempering. In some cases, cracks occur in the fine grained section of the heat affected zone of a weldment. The dmw can be deposited using either 9cr1mo filler metal or 2. Grades p11p22 and p91 92 are typically found in power stations, whereas grade p5 and p9 are more common for application in the petrochemical industry. Type iv inservice creep cracking at weld heataffected zones in leading power plant steels, such as p91 and p92, has often been considered to be a costly but unavoidable lifelimiting problem.
Astm a335 chromemoly alloy pipe specifications enpro pipe. Predicting the onset of type iv cracking in p91 parametric and model approaches. Effect of heat treatment on microstructure and hot impact. Type iv cracking is creep cracking which occurs at the parent material heat affected zone haz interface in ferritic steel weldments. With an evergrowing inventory and p91 materials of the best quality, u. Therefore, it is necessary to minimize the system stress of p91 steel. Review of type iv cracking of weldments in 912%cr creep strength enhanced ferritic steels. A characteristic m shaped distribution of stresses. This material has been in use for the last two decades successfully in power plant service.
They may not happen for days after the material has cooled down to ambient temperature. Special workshop explores p91t91 issues, impending asme. In a type iv failure, cracking takes place in the finegrain section on the basemetal side of the heataffected zone of a weldment. Creep crack growth behavior of a p91 steel weld core. Cracks that have been categorized as type i, type ii, type iii and type iv are given below. Thomas siempelkamp pruefund gutachtergesellschaft mbh. Increasing the postweld heattreating temperature from 600 c to 840 c causes a transition of creep rupture locations from the type iv cracking in the intercritical heataffected zone to the type. P91 heat treatment metal and metallurgy engineering. Comparing materials for hightemperature steam piping.
Metalspiping not only provides premiumquality t91 p91. Microstructure zones where type iv failures may occur have been studied in details. Metals looks to exceed customers expectation and deliver quality astm a335 p91 type 2 material. Type iv cracking in heat affected zone haz of weldments has long been recognised. There have only been about a dozen such failures in p91t91. The cracking was associated with extremely localised creep cavitation, which was confined to the type iv zone and the narrow band of material immediately adjacent to the cracking. Residual stresses in p91 steel electron beam welds. One hour per inch is common for most alloys, but newell recommends that heavywall greater than 3 4 in. Study of cracks in the weld metal joint of p91 steel of a superheater steam pipe. Dec 9 weldlife avoidance of p91 type iv failure in p91 and p92 steels. Study of cracks in the weld metal joint of p91 steel of a.
Weld p91 to p22 asme mechanical code issues engtips. Table 4 provides examples of welding consumables, and table 5 lists consumables for welding p91. It covers nominal wall and minimum wall thickness pipe that with alloy material. Type iv cracking of weldments in enhanced ferritic steels twi. The laterolet branch exhibited a microstructure of tempered martensite with a fine distribution of alloy carbide and carbonitride precipitates, typical of grade p91. Pdf predicting the onset of typeiv cracking in p91 parametric. P91 components should have a minimum soak time of two hours. Hydrogen embrittlement can lead to cold cracking of the finished weld. The problem is that type iv cracking in p91 only shows itself at about 80% of the life of the time to failure which i think could be very short in the high stressed locations. This type of wire offers a fastfreezing slag for outofposition welding, along with low diffusible hydrogen levels to control cracking. Material alloy steel uns k91560 astm a335 asme sa335 p91 pipe supplier, buy p91 chrome moly pipe in india.
P22 steel has a relatively small amount of t and weld filler metal, while p91 steel is sensitive to weld type iv cracks. Growing experience with p91t91 forcing essential code changes. Meet the demanding requirements of welding p91 pipe with. The cracking was not visible on the outside surface of the pipe. Creep strength behavior of boron added p91 steel and its weld in. Type iv cracking refers to the premature failure of a welded joint due to an. Etd consultingweldlife avoidance of p91 type iv failure. This is inherent with these materials and it has been well documented. The types of alloy steel covered by the astm a335 asme sa335 specification are designed with a p prefix, from p5 to p92. It is aimed at generating stress rupture data and estimating safe operating life of p91 welded components containing aberrant p91 base or weld metals the type often found in power plants and showing the. Also present are smaller quantities of nickel and manganese which increase the hardenability of astm a335 p91. It is also called 9 cr 1 mo steel based on its composition. The postheat temperature may be the same as, or greater than, the original preheat temperature specified.
Placing excessive amounts of weight on top of a concrete slab can cause cracking. However, the haz does not become brittle it actually softens the paper does not say that the haz becomes brittle. Few studies have been carried out on aberrant p91 materials welds, and the little information available in the public domain tends to suggest that, for certain material conditions, the creep. Bhadeshia3 there have been concerted world wide efforts to develop steels suitable for use in efficient fossil fired power plants. They can be welded by many common welding methods including smaw, saw, gsawtigmig, and fcaw, etc. Creep strengthenhanced ferritic steels, commonly known as crmo alloys such as p91 x10crmovnb 91 are such material of choice for the next generation power plants. If this temperature is exceeded as sometimes may happen due to errant.
P91 heat treatment unclesyd materials 25 jun 04 11. P91 is more sensitive to variations in chemistry and heat treatment than are p11 and p22. Increasingly demanding material requirements found in piping and boiler construction for industries such as power generation and petrochemical have made a specific type of chromiummolybdenum steel pipe referred to as grade p91 a frequent choice because of its ability to withstand high pressures and high temperatures. Abnormal p91 this 5year duration project started in april 2014. Influence of welding process on type iv cracking behavior. The new generation super critical thermal power plants are required to operate at enhanced thermal efficiency of over 50% to reduce the fuel consumption and environmental pollution. Microstructural characterization of p91 steel in the virgin, service exposed and postservice renormalized conditions abstract p91 steel has been widely used in power generation industry. Type iv cracking of weldments in enhanced ferritic steels. Troubling is that most of these failures were due to socalled type iv creep rupture midlife cracking, which occurs in as little as 20,00040,000 hours of service. One of the promising ways for mitigation of type iv cracking a failure by cracking at the intercritical fine grained heat affected zone, a life limiting problem in. Predicting the onset of typeiv cracking in p91 parametric and model. These are stress corrosion cracks scc occurring in aswelded state of material. P91 welding chromiummolybdenum steel is major material which is used in power plants. Of all the materials used for hightemperature steam piping, x20 12 percent chromium, 1 percent molybdenum, 1 4 percent vanadium and p91 9 percent chromium, 1 percent molybdenum, 1 4 percent vanadium stand out because of their very high creep rupture properties, even at.
P91 heatresistant steel pipes are widely used at high temperature in power plants and nuclear power plants. Astm a335 is the seamless ferritic alloy steel pipe that used in hightemperature services and boiler industry. This loss of carbon being primarily responsible for the infamous type iv cracking. T91 p91 steel manufactured to astm a335 p91 or astm a2 t91 is a typical tempered martensite in term of microstructure. Influence of welding process on type iv cracking behavior of p91 steel. Microstructural characterization of p91 steel in the. Handling ninechrome steel in hrsgs power engineering. Pdf predicting the onset of typeiv cracking in p91. Generally, p91 creep resisting steel is produced by normalizing and tempering. The novelty of the work lies in revealing the residual stress profile at a fine length scale associated with a.
Properties and welding procedure for grade 91 alloy steel. Nde techniques perhaps the most important takeaway from the 2003 maintenance workshop on p91 t91 was the need to closely monitor these advanced materials throughout their service lives. Pdf successful management of type iv cracking in advanced 9. P91special alloy steel for high temperature application. Influence of welding process on type iv cracking behavior of p91 steel article in materials science and engineering a 6. Thus, it occurs at the surface of the haz in the overtempered, intercritical or refined region of the haz. Grade 91 is classified as a creepstrength enhanced ferritic steel, and like all ferritic steels, itremains susceptible to type iv cracking.
319 897 260 510 907 731 1428 81 626 382 557 514 434 1585 1623 1570 1467 148 247 191 1053 1105 718 1382 1301 1557 532 219 408 150 1321 1008 930 962